FALL RIVER, Mass. – The Rev. Tom Cabral still tells people to meet him at “the bar,” even though it’s his church now.
Fall River resident best remember his worn building as a former sports bar where a 19-year-old once walked in and shot three suspected rival crack dealers.
Eight years later, the mirrored walls, parquet dance floor and bar remain. But the worst trouble might be found around the Sunday school table, where kids try to heed a handwritten list of rules including: “We will walk indoors, not run.”
Redemption Fellowship of Fall River is one of dozens of churches the Southern Baptist Convention has planted around New England in the last decade with a multimillion dollar push into territory skeptical of the South and increasingly indifferent to religion.
Cabral seems unfazed. He’s “indigenous,” he said, a native of nearby Somerset, Mass.
He also is so eager to share his faith that he regularly carries a wood cross emblazoned with the words “Are You Ready?” to a traffic island in this southeastern Massachusetts city and evangelizes to anyone who rolls down their window.
“I really believe that God wants to change this city,” he said.
Since 2002, Southern Baptists have spent roughly $5 million to plant churches around the region, and have another $800,000 committed for this year, said Jim Wideman, executive director of the Baptist Convention of New England, the Southern Baptist’s regional church-planting arm.
They’ve started 133 new churches in that time, a nearly 70 percent increase that brings their regional total to 325.
No denomination is investing as much in New England church planting, though attendance isn’t growing as fast as the number of churches, said Scott Thumma, a Hartford Seminary professor.
The roughly 30,500 members the denomination had in New England 2010 is a 20 percent increase from a decade ago, according to the Association of Statisticians of American Religious Bodies. That growth is about the same as another religiously conservative group, the Assemblies of God, which hasn’t emphasized church planting.
Southern Baptists are drawing immigrants and new residents, Thumma said, but there’s little proof they’ve reaching lifelong residents, including the large Roman Catholic population and increasing numbers of secularists.
“I don’t see a third Great Awakening happening at the moment,” Thumma said.
A Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life study last year found that since 2007, the Northeast had the largest percentage increase nationwide of people who describe themselves as religiously unaffiliated. Meanwhile, a 2012 Gallup poll indicates the six-state New England region has five of the nation’s least religious states.
Southern Baptists, the nation’s largest Protestant group with about 16 million members, have been trying since the late 1950s to build a northern presence. But their vigorous, recent church-planting is part of a broader, denomination-wide emphasis at a time when overall membership is declining.
Wideman said research indicates that the unchurched are far more likely to be drawn to a new church than one that already exists. Multiple church plants in neighborhood-centric urban areas, though unlikely to draw huge numbers, also aim to create enduring Southern Baptist communities, he said.
A similarity among the New England church plants is that none of their names include the words “Southern Baptist.”
That is a clear effort to avoid some of the stereotypes about Southerners, such as negative perceptions of their racial views or reputed “damn-us-all-to-hell” fundamentalism, Thumma said. It’s not malicious, he said, but “they’re church-planting by stealth.”
Wideman said the churches never deny they’re Southern Baptist, but if it’s a barrier to sharing the faith, why broadcast it?
The Southern Baptist Convention itself has acknowledged this problem by approving an optional alternative name last summer: Great Commission Baptists.
The main concern, Wideman said, is that Northerners will see the churches as excluding them. He also has a question for Southern friends who complain about the tactic: “How well do you think ‘First Yankee Baptist Church’ would go over in Alabama?”
With a thick North Carolina accent, Lyandon Warren can’t hide his roots. But in seven years planting churches in West Pawlet and Poultney, Vt., he finds showing a commitment to the local community is more important.
Many New Englanders have no familiarity with the Bible, so you can’t just throw open the doors of a new church and expect people to come in, he said. Instead, his group reached out with novel approaches like offering water and a diaper-changing station at a townwide tag sale.
In Norwich, Conn., the Rev. Shaun Pillay’s group volunteers for various tasks, from filling sand bags to snow shoveling. It creates a foothold and trust in the community, if not converts, he said.
“They say, ‘We like what you do, but we don’t like your God,’” Pillay said.
Persistence is critical, said Pillay and Warren, who emphasize showing up at the same place, at the same times, with the same Christian message, as does Cabral with his cross at the Fall River intersection.
Cabral’s consistency paid off with Angelique Vargas, who was so drunk she didn’t remember the first three times she met her future pastor. But on a sober day, the 39-year-old was surprised when a stranger called her by name as she crossed the street. She listened to his message, Vargas said, “for the simple fact that he remembered me on my darkest day.”
On a recent February afternoon, horns honked and a middle finger flew as Cabral walked the traffic island. Drivers also kept engaging him, trying to answer the question on his cross, which he’d explain meant, “Are you ready to face God when you die?” Cabral would share how he knew that he was, then hand out a card with a gospel message and his church’s address.
“God bless you!” he’d call as the light changed. “I want you to go to heaven!”
Cabral’s church has 35 members, a fraction compared to that of larger Southern Baptist churches. But Cabral said he’s not going anywhere. He wants to love people, give them a chance to let God change them and see how this church plant goes.
“It’s like growing a garden,” he said. “You’ve got to plant the seed, you’ve got to water it and you’ve got to be faithful.”